Cooper’s Mill

670 White Plains Rd. Tarrytown, NY 10591 • (914) 333-1216 • coopersmillrestaurant.com
 scallops-at-coopers-mill-600x398

Unfortunately we got duped into coming here via an Amazon Local Deal, not realizing the place was in a Marriott Hotel- which would’ve been a big enough red flag to warrant a pass on the deal. That said, the menu really does read well. But regrettably that would be just the menu. The preparations, for whatever reason, just don’t translate to taste. Virtually everything we had would be exactly what you’d expect from a massive hotel chain restaurant.

The salad, flatbread, fish and ice cream were all underwhelming. The only thing that rose to a level of okay, would be the burger. But not even the burger was worth the trip.

And the egg nog ice cream was flat out disgusting. Tasted like a bird was dying in my mouth.

On a plus note, our server was excellent. Oh, and I’m glad we didn’t pay full price for it.

2 teeth